9+ Obsidian Dataview: Hide Empty Query Results


9+ Obsidian Dataview: Hide Empty Query Results

Conditional display of dynamic content within notes, generated from the note’s metadata and content using a query language, can be achieved through clever use of inline JavaScript within Dataview queries. This allows the query results to be evaluated, and if no results match the provided criteria, the entire output, including any surrounding markup, can be suppressed. For instance, a DataviewJS query can check for the presence of specific keywords or tags within a note, and render content only when those conditions are met. A practical example involves displaying a specific section of a project overview note only if the project is marked as “active.”

This dynamic control over content visibility offers significant advantages for note organization and knowledge management. It allows for the creation of flexible and adaptable templates that adjust their output based on the data within each note. This minimizes clutter and presents only the most relevant information, streamlining workflows and enhancing the usability of interconnected notes. Historically, achieving such dynamic behavior required more complex workarounds or third-party plugins, but with the integration of JavaScript into Dataview, this functionality becomes more readily accessible.

The following sections will delve into specific techniques for implementing this conditional display, covering both simple and complex scenarios with illustrative examples. This will include explanations of how to integrate JavaScript within Dataview queries, different approaches for conditional logic, and practical tips for optimizing query performance and maintaining readability.

1. Conditional Logic

Conditional logic forms the core of controlling Dataview query visibility. By leveraging JavaScript’s `if/else` statements within DataviewJS queries, one can determine whether the results of a query should be rendered. This allows for precise control over the display of dynamic content. For example, if a query searches for notes tagged with “project/active” and no such notes exist, the conditional logic can prevent the display of the associated project summary section, keeping the note uncluttered.

The absence of conditional logic would necessitate displaying all possible output regardless of the query results. This could lead to irrelevant information cluttering notes, especially when dealing with numerous dynamic sections based on varying criteria. Consider a dashboard view aggregating tasks from different projects. Without conditional logic, empty project sections would still appear, even if those projects currently have no tasks. Conditional logic prevents this by ensuring only sections with actual data are rendered. Another practical application lies in displaying meeting notes only when a “meeting/completed” tag exists on a daily note, keeping the daily note focused on current tasks until the meeting concludes.

Effective utilization of conditional logic within DataviewJS queries is crucial for dynamic content management within Obsidian. This approach enables responsive templates that adapt to changing data, minimizing clutter and enhancing overall note organization. The ability to suppress empty query results significantly contributes to a more streamlined and focused workflow by ensuring only relevant information is presented based on the current data state.

2. JavaScript Integration

JavaScript integration within Dataview provides the core mechanism for achieving conditional rendering of query results. Without JavaScript, Dataview queries function primarily as templated displays of existing data, lacking the ability to react dynamically to the presence or absence of results. JavaScript empowers users to introduce logic that governs the display of information based on the outcome of queries, enabling sophisticated control over content visibility.

  • Conditional Rendering:

    JavaScript’s `if/else` statements, when embedded within DataviewJS code blocks, allow for the conditional execution of code based on query results. This enables dynamic rendering where content associated with a query is displayed only if the query returns data. This is the fundamental principle behind making a Dataview query “disappear” when no results are found. A practical example involves a task list query that only renders if tasks tagged with a specific project exist.

  • Data Manipulation and Transformation:

    Beyond simply checking for the presence of results, JavaScript allows for data manipulation and transformation prior to rendering. This can involve filtering, sorting, or aggregating data returned by the query. For instance, one could filter a list of files to display only those modified within the last week, and then conditionally render the list only if files meet that criteria. This further refines the control over what information is displayed, dynamically adjusting the output based on more complex data criteria.

  • Custom Function Creation:

    JavaScript allows for the creation of custom functions within DataviewJS queries. These functions can encapsulate complex logic for determining content visibility, enabling greater code reusability and maintainability. A function could be defined to check for specific conditions across multiple metadata fields and return a boolean value determining whether a section should be rendered. This promotes a more modular and organized approach to managing conditional rendering logic.

  • Interaction with the Obsidian API:

    While not directly related to making Dataview content disappear, JavaScript integration within Dataview allows for interaction with the Obsidian API. This unlocks potential for more advanced dynamic behaviors, such as programmatically opening notes or manipulating the Obsidian interface based on query results. While this extends beyond the core scope of conditional rendering, it highlights the broader power and flexibility offered by JavaScript within the Dataview context.

These facets of JavaScript integration collectively empower users to create highly dynamic and responsive note templates. By leveraging JavaScript’s logical capabilities and its interaction with Dataview and the Obsidian API, content can be precisely controlled, ensuring only relevant information is presented based on the underlying data. This granular control over content visibility is essential for maintaining organized and efficient knowledge management workflows within Obsidian.

3. DataviewJS Queries

DataviewJS queries provide the essential mechanism for implementing conditional rendering, thus controlling the visibility of dynamic content within Obsidian notes. Unlike standard Dataview queries, which primarily focus on data retrieval and templating, DataviewJS queries incorporate JavaScript, enabling logical operations and conditional execution of code. This allows results to be evaluated before rendering, providing the ability to suppress output entirely if specific criteria are not met. This addresses the core objective of making content disappear when no relevant data exists. A practical example involves a query displaying a list of project tasks. A DataviewJS query can check if any tasks exist for a given project and conditionally render the list, ensuring empty project sections do not clutter the note.

The integration of JavaScript within DataviewJS queries allows for sophisticated control over the displayed content. Conditions can range from simple checks for the presence of data to complex evaluations involving multiple metadata fields or external data sources. Consider a scenario where a note displays information about upcoming deadlines. A DataviewJS query could filter tasks by due date, and then conditionally render the “Upcoming Deadlines” section only if tasks are due within the next week. This dynamic behavior ensures the note remains relevant and avoids displaying empty sections when no immediate deadlines exist. Another example involves dynamically generating tables of contents based on the headings within a note. The query can check for the presence of headings before rendering the table of contents, ensuring its visibility only when the note structure necessitates it.

Leveraging DataviewJS queries for conditional rendering significantly contributes to efficient information management within Obsidian. By controlling the visibility of dynamic content based on data availability, notes remain uncluttered and focused on relevant information. This approach fosters a more streamlined workflow, reducing cognitive overhead and enhancing the overall user experience. The ability to dynamically adjust content visibility contributes to a more adaptable and responsive knowledge management system, accommodating evolving information landscapes and user-specific needs.

4. Empty Result Handling

Empty result handling is crucial for achieving clean and efficient conditional rendering within Dataview. When a Dataview query yields no results, the default behavior is often to display an empty placeholder or, in some cases, an error message. This can lead to cluttered notes filled with irrelevant or distracting elements, counteracting the goal of dynamic content display. Effective empty result handling provides the mechanism to completely suppress the output of a query, including any surrounding markup, when no data matches the specified criteria. This directly addresses the challenge of making Dataview content disappear when no results are found.

Consider a dashboard displaying project statuses. Without proper empty result handling, projects without updates might still occupy space, displaying empty sections or placeholders. This clutters the dashboard and diminishes its effectiveness. By implementing empty result handling within the DataviewJS query, the project sections disappear entirely when no relevant data exists, resulting in a clean and focused view of active projects. Similarly, imagine a daily note template that displays meeting notes. If no meeting occurred on a particular day, an empty “Meeting Notes” section would appear. Empty result handling ensures this section only renders when meeting notes exist, maintaining a streamlined daily note structure. In more complex scenarios, such as dynamically generated bibliographies, empty result handling prevents the display of empty citation lists when no sources are relevant to a particular document, maintaining a polished and professional appearance.

Effective empty result handling is inextricably linked to the ability to create truly dynamic and contextually relevant notes. By suppressing irrelevant content, focus is maintained on the information that matters, leading to improved clarity and a more efficient workflow. Challenges may arise in complex queries where determining empty results requires nuanced logic, but the benefits of a clean and responsive note structure outweigh the implementation effort. Mastering empty result handling is essential for leveraging the full potential of Dataview and optimizing knowledge management within Obsidian.

5. Dynamic Content

Dynamic content lies at the heart of achieving conditional visibility within Dataview. The ability to generate content that adapts to changing data and user-specified criteria is fundamental to creating responsive and uncluttered notes. Controlling the display of this dynamic content, specifically making it disappear when no relevant data exists, is the key focus of optimizing Dataview for efficient knowledge management. This involves a deeper understanding of how dynamic content is generated and how its visibility can be managed based on query results.

  • Context-Aware Information:

    Dynamic content adapts to the specific context of a note. Rather than statically displaying all possible information, dynamic content is generated based on the current data within the note and related files. This context-awareness is crucial for displaying only relevant information. For example, a project overview note might dynamically display tasks, deadlines, and relevant files based on the project’s current status. If no tasks are assigned, the task list disappears, ensuring the note remains focused on the relevant information. This adaptability is crucial for maintaining clean and efficient note structures.

  • Query-Driven Generation:

    Dataview queries drive the generation of dynamic content. These queries, often based on metadata or content within notes, retrieve and filter information, forming the basis for dynamic displays. The query results dictate what content is generated and ultimately displayed. For instance, a query filtering tasks by due date can populate a dynamic task list, ensuring only upcoming tasks are visible. This query-driven approach is essential for creating flexible and adaptable note templates that respond to evolving data.

  • Conditional Visibility Control:

    Conditional logic, primarily implemented through JavaScript within DataviewJS queries, governs the visibility of dynamic content. This logic evaluates query results and determines whether or not the associated content should be rendered. The ability to make content disappear when no results are found relies entirely on this conditional control. A classic example involves a meeting notes section that only appears if a meeting occurred on a given day, preventing empty sections from cluttering daily notes.

  • Template-Based Rendering:

    Templates provide the structure for displaying dynamic content. They define how the data retrieved by queries is formatted and presented within the note. This separation of content and presentation allows for consistent formatting while maintaining dynamic adaptability. For instance, a template might define the layout of a task list, while the actual tasks displayed are dynamically populated based on query results. This structured approach ensures consistency and maintainability while allowing for flexible content updates.

These facets of dynamic content demonstrate its integral role in achieving conditional visibility within Dataview. By combining query-driven generation with conditional visibility control and template-based rendering, users gain fine-grained control over what information is displayed, ensuring notes remain focused and relevant. This dynamic approach is crucial for creating adaptable note systems that effectively support evolving knowledge management needs within Obsidian.

6. Metadata Filtering

Metadata filtering plays a critical role in controlling the visibility of dynamic content generated by Dataview queries. The ability to selectively query data based on metadata allows for precise control over which information is retrieved and subsequently displayed. This selective retrieval forms the foundation for conditional rendering, enabling dynamic content to appear only when relevant metadata is present. Without metadata filtering, conditional rendering would lack the necessary granularity to determine what content should be displayed based on the specific context of a note.

  • Targeted Data Retrieval:

    Metadata filtering enables targeted data retrieval by specifying criteria that must be met for data to be included in query results. This allows for the creation of highly specific queries that extract only the desired information from a collection of notes. For example, filtering for notes tagged with “project/active” ensures only active project notes are considered for dynamic content generation. This targeted retrieval is crucial for ensuring the displayed content accurately reflects the current context and avoids cluttering notes with irrelevant information.

  • Conditional Rendering Foundation:

    Metadata filtering provides the foundation for conditional rendering by determining whether or not data exists that matches specific criteria. If no data meets the filter criteria, the associated dynamic content can be suppressed. This direct link between filtering and rendering is essential for making content disappear when no relevant information exists. Consider a task list filtered by project tag. If no tasks exist for a particular project, metadata filtering ensures the query returns no results, triggering the conditional logic to suppress the task list display.

  • Dynamic Content Control:

    Metadata filtering enables fine-grained control over dynamic content visibility. By combining multiple metadata filters, complex conditions can be defined to precisely control when content appears. For example, filtering for tasks tagged with “priority/high” and due within the next week allows for a dynamic display of urgent tasks. This level of control ensures users see only the most critical information, streamlining workflows and reducing cognitive overload.

  • Contextual Relevance:

    Metadata filtering enhances the contextual relevance of dynamic content by tailoring the displayed information to the specific circumstances within a note. This ensures the displayed information aligns with the note’s purpose and avoids presenting irrelevant data. For instance, a daily note template could use metadata filtering to display only meetings scheduled for that specific day, maintaining a focused and relevant daily overview.

These facets of metadata filtering highlight its integral role in controlling dynamic content visibility. By enabling precise data retrieval, providing the basis for conditional rendering, and enhancing contextual relevance, metadata filtering empowers users to create highly adaptable and focused note systems. Without effective metadata filtering, achieving the core objective of making Dataview content disappear when no results are found becomes significantly more challenging. The combination of metadata filtering and conditional logic within DataviewJS queries provides the essential tools for managing information effectively and maintaining a streamlined workflow within Obsidian.

7. Template Flexibility

Template flexibility is essential for effectively managing dynamic content visibility within Dataview, particularly when aiming to suppress output when queries yield no results. Adaptable templates allow content structures to adjust dynamically based on data availability, ensuring only relevant information is displayed. This adaptability is crucial for maintaining clean and focused notes, preventing empty sections or placeholders from cluttering the interface when queries return no data. Without template flexibility, achieving conditional rendering and controlling content visibility becomes significantly more challenging.

  • Conditional Sections:

    Templates can incorporate conditional sections that appear or disappear based on query results. This allows entire blocks of content, such as project summaries or task lists, to be rendered only when relevant data exists. A project management template could include a task list section that only appears if tasks are assigned to that project. This prevents empty task lists from cluttering project notes when no tasks are present, maintaining a focused and uncluttered view.

  • Variable Content Inclusion:

    Template flexibility extends to variable content inclusion. Specific elements within a template can be dynamically populated or omitted based on data availability. Consider a book review template. A section for quotes could be conditionally included only if quotes have been added to the note. This avoids displaying empty quote sections, maintaining a streamlined template structure that adapts to the available information. This level of control enhances the template’s reusability across various contexts.

  • Iterative Rendering:

    Templates can leverage iterative rendering to generate repeating content blocks based on query results. For example, a meeting notes template can utilize iterative rendering to create a separate section for each attendee, displaying their individual contributions. If an attendee did not contribute, the corresponding section can be omitted, ensuring only relevant participant information is displayed. This avoids unnecessary repetition and maintains a concise meeting summary.

  • Nested Conditionals:

    More complex templates can incorporate nested conditional logic, allowing for nuanced control over content visibility. A template summarizing research papers could include a section for experimental results, which further contains subsections for different experimental conditions. These subsections could be conditionally rendered based on the availability of data for each condition. This granular control ensures only relevant experimental data is displayed, maintaining a clean and organized structure even within complex research summaries.

These facets of template flexibility underscore its importance in achieving dynamic content control within Dataview. By enabling conditional sections, variable content inclusion, iterative rendering, and nested conditionals, templates become powerful tools for creating adaptable and responsive notes. This flexibility directly addresses the core objective of making Dataview content disappear when no results are found, contributing to a more efficient and uncluttered note-taking experience within Obsidian.

8. Workflow Enhancement

Workflow enhancement is a direct consequence of effectively managing dynamic content visibility within Dataview. The ability to suppress query results when no data exists, effectively making content disappear, streamlines information access and reduces cognitive overhead. This contributes to a more focused and efficient workflow by presenting only relevant information, eliminating the need to sift through empty sections or irrelevant data. Consider a researcher using Obsidian to manage literature notes. Without conditional rendering, literature reviews might contain numerous empty sections for papers lacking specific data points (e.g., experimental results, specific methodologies). By conditionally displaying these sections only when data exists, the researcher gains a clearer overview of the relevant literature, focusing solely on papers pertinent to the current research question. This targeted information access directly translates into a more efficient literature review process.

The practical significance of this workflow enhancement extends to various scenarios. Project managers using Obsidian for task management benefit from dynamic task lists that only display tasks relevant to the current project phase. Empty project sections are eliminated, providing a focused view of active tasks and streamlining project tracking. Similarly, writers can use conditional rendering to dynamically display relevant research notes, outlines, or character sketches based on the current writing context. This eliminates distractions and ensures only pertinent information is readily available, fostering a more focused and productive writing environment. In software development, dynamic documentation generated through Dataview can conditionally display code examples, API references, or troubleshooting steps based on the current development task. This context-sensitive information delivery minimizes search time and accelerates the development process.

Conditional content visibility, achieved through techniques like DataviewJS and strategic metadata filtering, is essential for workflow optimization within Obsidian. While initial setup may require a deeper understanding of Dataview’s capabilities, the resulting improvements in information access and cognitive efficiency significantly enhance productivity. The ability to tailor information display to specific contexts reduces clutter, minimizes distractions, and ultimately fosters a more streamlined and effective workflow across diverse knowledge work domains. The challenge lies in striking a balance between template complexity and maintainability, ensuring the benefits of conditional rendering outweigh the overhead of implementing and managing complex queries. This careful balance allows users to fully leverage the power of Dataview for enhanced knowledge management and workflow optimization.

9. Improved Readability

Improved readability is a direct consequence of controlling dynamic content visibility within Obsidian notes using Dataview. By suppressing the display of irrelevant or empty query results, notes become more focused and easier to parse. This enhanced readability stems from reducing visual clutter and cognitive overhead associated with processing unnecessary information. Consider a dashboard view aggregating information from multiple sources. Without conditional rendering, empty sections corresponding to data-deficient sources would clutter the view, hindering quick comprehension. Conditional display ensures only sections with actual data are rendered, significantly improving the dashboard’s at-a-glance readability. Similarly, in a daily note incorporating dynamic task lists, suppressing empty lists for projects without current tasks declutters the note, allowing for rapid assessment of daily priorities.

The practical significance of this improved readability extends beyond simple visual clarity. In complex research notes, dynamically hiding irrelevant literature summaries or experimental data based on specific queries dramatically improves comprehension. The reader’s attention remains focused on the pertinent information, reducing the cognitive effort required to extract key insights. This targeted information presentation allows for more efficient analysis and synthesis of complex research materials. In project management contexts, dynamically hiding completed tasks or irrelevant project details streamlines project tracking. The project overview becomes more concise, facilitating quick assessments of project status and upcoming milestones. This efficient information access contributes to improved decision-making and project execution. In collaborative writing scenarios, dynamically controlling section visibility allows writers to focus on specific aspects of a document, such as character development, plot outlines, or research materials, without being distracted by irrelevant sections.

Conditional content visibility, therefore, is crucial for maximizing readability within Obsidian. While achieving dynamic control may require initial effort in setting up Dataview queries and JavaScript logic, the resulting improvements in readability contribute significantly to more efficient knowledge management and improved cognitive focus. Challenges may arise in balancing template complexity with maintainability, requiring careful consideration of query structure and conditional logic. Ultimately, the benefits of enhanced readability, enabling rapid information assimilation and reduced cognitive burden, outweigh the initial investment in establishing effective conditional rendering strategies. This careful balance allows users to fully leverage the power of Dataview and transform Obsidian into a truly responsive and efficient knowledge management tool.

Frequently Asked Questions

This section addresses common queries regarding the conditional display of Dataview content within Obsidian, focusing on techniques to suppress output when query results are empty.

Question 1: What are the primary methods for hiding Dataview content when no results are found?

The primary method involves using DataviewJS, which allows JavaScript code to control rendering logic based on query outcomes. Specifically, `if/else` statements within the JavaScript code can check for empty result sets and prevent content rendering.

Question 2: How does JavaScript integration enhance control over Dataview output?

JavaScript provides the logical framework necessary for conditional rendering. Without JavaScript, Dataview primarily functions as a templating engine, lacking the ability to react dynamically to query results. JavaScript allows for more complex evaluations and control over what is displayed based on those results.

Question 3: Can standard Dataview queries achieve the same conditional rendering as DataviewJS?

Standard Dataview queries offer limited conditional rendering capabilities. While some basic filtering can be achieved, complex logic requiring evaluations and conditional display of content necessitates the use of DataviewJS.

Question 4: Are there performance considerations when using JavaScript within Dataview?

Complex JavaScript code within Dataview queries can potentially impact performance, particularly with large datasets or complex conditions. Optimizing JavaScript code for efficiency and minimizing unnecessary computations can mitigate potential performance bottlenecks.

Question 5: How can metadata influence the conditional display of content?

Metadata acts as the primary filter for Dataview queries. By defining specific metadata criteria, queries can selectively retrieve data. This targeted data retrieval forms the basis for conditional rendering, as the presence or absence of specific metadata determines whether content is displayed.

Question 6: What are the advantages of using dynamic content control compared to static content display?

Dynamic content adapts to changing data and user-specified criteria, creating more responsive and uncluttered notes. Static content remains fixed regardless of data changes, leading to potential redundancy and reduced readability. Dynamic content, controlled effectively, ensures only relevant information is displayed, enhancing clarity and efficiency.

Mastering conditional rendering techniques empowers users to create adaptable, focused, and highly readable notes. By understanding the interplay between DataviewJS, metadata filtering, and template design, one can effectively harness the full power of Dataview for enhanced knowledge management within Obsidian.

The following section will delve into specific code examples and practical implementation strategies for conditional content display within Dataview.

Practical Tips for Conditional Dataview Rendering

These tips provide practical guidance for implementing conditional content display within Dataview, focusing on suppressing output when queries yield no results. Effective implementation enhances note organization, readability, and overall workflow efficiency within Obsidian.

Tip 1: Utilize `dv.pages(”)` for Empty Array Checks: When checking for empty arrays returned by Dataview queries, employing `dv.pages(”)` within a conditional statement offers a concise and reliable method. This ensures the code block executes only when results exist, preventing unnecessary rendering of empty sections. Example: `if (dv.pages(‘”tag”‘).length > 0) { }`

Tip 2: Leverage the `none` Keyword for Empty Result Handling: The `none` keyword within DataviewJS provides a streamlined approach to handling empty query results. This keyword simplifies the conditional logic, making templates cleaner and easier to maintain. Example: `dv.pages(‘”tag”‘) or “No results found.”`

Tip 3: Employ `if/else` Statements for Complex Conditional Logic: For more complex scenarios involving multiple conditions or data manipulations, JavaScript’s `if/else` statements offer granular control over content rendering. This enables tailored display logic based on various data states. Example: “`javascript if (dv.pages(‘”tag1″ and “tag2″‘).length > 0) { dv.taskList(dv.pages(‘”tag1” and “tag2″‘)); } else if (dv.pages(‘”tag1″‘).length > 0) { dv.paragraph(“Only tag1 found.”); } else { dv.paragraph(“No matching tags found.”); } “`

Tip 4: Structure Templates for Clear Conditional Rendering: Organizing templates with distinct sections for conditionally rendered content improves maintainability and readability. This clear separation facilitates debugging and modification of rendering logic. Example: Using HTML `

` elements with distinct IDs or classes to encapsulate conditionally rendered blocks allows for targeted control through JavaScript.

Tip 5: Optimize Queries for Performance: Complex queries or large datasets can impact rendering performance. Optimizing query logic, using appropriate filters, and minimizing unnecessary calculations improves efficiency. Consider pre-filtering data or using more specific query parameters to reduce the load on Dataview.

Tip 6: Comment Code for Clarity: Adding comments within DataviewJS code blocks enhances maintainability and facilitates understanding of complex rendering logic. This is particularly important for collaborative projects or revisiting templates after a period of time. Clear comments explain the purpose and logic of conditional rendering, simplifying future modifications.

Tip 7: Test Thoroughly with Varied Data: Thorough testing with diverse datasets is essential for ensuring the reliability of conditional rendering logic. Test with empty result sets, small datasets, and large datasets to ensure consistent and predictable behavior across various scenarios.

By implementing these tips, users gain significant control over the presentation of dynamic content within Obsidian, improving note organization, readability, and overall workflow efficiency. These techniques enable the creation of adaptable and responsive notes that present only the most relevant information based on underlying data and user-defined criteria.

The subsequent conclusion synthesizes the key benefits and broader implications of mastering conditional content visibility within Obsidian.

Conclusion

Effective management of dynamic content visibility within Obsidian, specifically the ability to suppress Dataview output when queries yield no results, significantly enhances knowledge management workflows. Leveraging DataviewJS, metadata filtering, and flexible template design empowers users to create highly adaptable and responsive notes. Conditional rendering eliminates clutter, improves readability, and streamlines information access, allowing users to focus on relevant data. Key techniques discussed include leveraging `dv.pages(”)` for empty array checks, utilizing the `none` keyword for simplified empty result handling, employing `if/else` statements for complex logic, structuring templates for clear conditional rendering, optimizing queries for performance, commenting code for clarity, and thorough testing with varied datasets. These practices ensure robust and reliable dynamic content control within Obsidian.

Mastering these techniques offers a pathway to a more efficient and focused knowledge management experience. The ability to tailor information display to specific contexts, ensuring only pertinent data is presented, unlocks the true potential of Obsidian as a dynamic and adaptable knowledge management tool. Continued exploration and refinement of conditional rendering strategies will further empower users to navigate complex information landscapes and maximize the effectiveness of their digital knowledge repositories.

Leave a Comment